Custom Mouthguards Near Me: Better Protection for Your Smile



Make an Appointment

Custom Mouthguards Near Me: Better Protection for Your Smile

Written by Dr. Jesse Hofer, DMD     March 27, 2025 20:14

At Precision Oyster Bay, we’ve seen firsthand how a well-fitted mouthguard can make all the difference—whether you're an athlete looking to prevent injuries, someone struggling with nighttime teeth grinding, or a patient needing extra protection for dental work.

Many people don’t realize that not all mouthguards are created equal. While store-bought options might seem convenient, they often fall short in protection, comfort, and durability. A custom mouthguard from your dentist is designed to fit your exact dental structure, giving you superior protection and a more comfortable experience—and that’s exactly what we offer here at our Oyster Bay practice.

In this guide, we’ll break down why custom mouthguards are worth the investment, how they compare to over-the-counter options, and exactly what to expect from the process.

💡 If you're looking for a high-quality, custom-fit mouthguard, check out Precision Oyster Bay’s sleep apnea dental services or call us today at 516-922-5730—we’d love to assist you!

Custom Mouthguards Near Me: Finding the Best Fit for Protection

If you find yourself searching for “custom mouthguards near me,” you might fall into one of three categories:

✔️ You play sports and want to prevent dental injuries.

✔️ You grind your teeth at night (also known as bruxism) and need relief from jaw pain or headaches.

✔️ You have dental work, such as braces or implants, and need protection.

No matter the reason, a custom dental sports mouthguard provides a level of protection that store-bought options simply can’t match.

Custom vs. Store-Bought Mouthguards: The Key Differences

There’s a huge difference between a custom mouthguard made by your dentist and a generic one from a store. Let’s break it down:

Feature
Custom Mouthguard
Store-Bought Mouthguard
Fit & Comfort
Made from a dental impression of your teeth, ensuring a perfect fit
One-size-fits-all or boil-and-bite, often uncomfortable
Protection Level
High – designed for your specific bite and jaw alignment
Low – less effective at absorbing impact
Durability
Can last years with proper care
Wears down quickly, often needs replacing every few months
Breathing & Speaking
Easy to talk and breathe while wearing
Often bulky, making it hard to speak clearly
Best For
Athletes, nighttime grinders, and people with dental work
Basic protection, but not ideal for long-term use

If you’re serious about protecting your teeth, jaw, and overall health, a custom mouthguard is the best investment you can make.

Why Custom Dental Mouthguards Offer Superior Protection

Here at Precision Oyster Bay, we’ve seen just how powerful a custom mouthguard can be in preventing dental emergencies—especially for our active patients. Whether it's a teenager gearing up for lacrosse season or an adult patient who grinds their teeth at night, we’ve crafted mouthguards for all types of smiles and situations.

Unlike one-size-fits-all versions from the store, a professionally made mouthguard is designed with your exact bite in mind. That means more than just comfort—it means real protection that adapts to your mouth’s natural shape.

A properly fitted custom mouthguard doesn’t just shield your teeth—it can help prevent some of the most common and painful injuries we see in our chairs:

🦷 Chipped or broken teeth

🦷 Lip, cheek, and tongue injuries

🦷 Jaw fractures or strain on the temporomandibular joint (TMJ)

🦷 Concussions and head trauma from high-impact sports

Because custom guards are designed for you, they stay in place securely and distribute the force of impact evenly—reducing the chance of serious injury. We've had patients return to tell us their mouthguard saved their smile after a nasty fall on the field. That kind of protection? You just don’t get that from a boil-and-bite.

Benefits of Custom Mouthguards for Athletes and Sports Enthusiasts

If you’re an athlete—or the parent of one—you know that sports come with risks. And while helmets and pads are a given, your teeth deserve protection, too.

At Precision Oyster Bay, we work with local athletes from Oyster Bay and beyond to make sure their smiles are game-ready. Whether it's a high school basketball player, a weekend hockey warrior, or a young gymnast, we’ve designed mouthguards for a wide range of athletic needs.

Here's why athletes love our custom mouthguards:

✔️ Better Shock Absorption – Unlike generic guards, ours are made from high-quality, lab-crafted material that absorbs and distributes impact efficiently. That means fewer cracked teeth—and fewer trips to the emergency dentist.

✔️ Secure Fit – Because it’s molded specifically to your teeth, your mouthguard won’t shift, slip, or fall out during the heat of the game. No distractions, no adjustments—your custom fit stays in place.

✔️ Breathability – You can breathe, speak, and stay focused without a bulky piece of plastic shifting around in your mouth. We hear it all the time: “I forgot I was even wearing it.”

No matter your sport or skill level, we’ll help you protect your winning smile.

How Custom Dental Sports Mouthguards Prevent Injuries

You wouldn’t wear sneakers that don’t fit, right? So why settle for a mouthguard that wasn’t made for your bite?

The right mouthguard doesn’t just soften the blow—it spreads out the impact force across the jaw and teeth, reducing the likelihood of damage. This helps prevent:

  • Cracked or dislodged teeth
  • Cuts and bruising inside the mouth
  • Jaw strain or dislocation
  • Long-term bite issues from repeated trauma

Studies have shown that athletes who wear custom mouthguards are significantly less likely to experience dental trauma than those using store-bought versions.

That’s why professional athletes—and smart parents of young athletes—choose custom mouthguards for maximum safety.

For growing kids and teens, custom mouthguards are especially important. At Precision Oyster Bay, we’ve worked with many families in our community to ensure young athletes stay protected as their mouths develop and change.

We’ve even had parents stop by after a season ends to thank us for giving them peace of mind. That’s why we take the time to ensure each mouthguard is made with real care—from your first consultation to final fitting.

Custom Mouthguards for Sleep Apnea and Snoring

Most people associate mouthguards with sports—but they’re just as powerful a tool for improving sleep and overall health.

If you or a loved one snores heavily or has been diagnosed with obstructive sleep apnea (OSA), you know how disruptive it can be. Fatigue, irritability, brain fog—these symptoms add up. Left untreated, sleep apnea can also increase your risk for high blood pressure, heart disease, and other serious health issues.

At Precision Oyster Bay, we create custom oral appliances—similar to mouthguards—that gently reposition your jaw during sleep to keep your airway open. These devices are FDA-approved alternatives to bulky CPAP machines and are especially popular with patients looking for a more natural, travel-friendly solution.

The Benefits of Custom Mouthguards for Sleep Apnea Patients

💤 Improved Sleep Quality – By maintaining an open airway, these devices promote uninterrupted sleep.

😴 Comfortable & Quiet – No hoses, no masks, no noise—just a discreet, snug appliance that helps you breathe better.

✈️ Portable & Travel-Friendly – Easy to slip into a suitcase or backpack so you can sleep well wherever you go.

If you’re struggling with snoring or a sleep apnea diagnosis, you’re not alone—and there’s a good chance a custom mouthguard could help. We’d be happy to walk you through your options and see if oral appliance therapy is the right fit for you.

The Process of Getting a Custom Mouthguard from a Dentist

We know the idea of getting a dental impression might sound intimidating, but we promise—it’s easier (and faster) than you think.

At Precision Oyster Bay, here’s how we make the process smooth and stress-free:

1️⃣ Consultation & Impression – We start by sitting down with you to understand what the mouthguard will be used for—sports? Grinding? Sleep apnea? Then, we take a quick, comfortable impression of your teeth, which becomes the blueprint for your custom guard.

2️⃣ Custom Fabrication – We send your impression to a trusted dental lab, where technicians craft your guard with top-tier materials that balance comfort, flexibility, and durability. These aren’t made on an assembly line—they’re made specifically for your smile.

3️⃣ Fitting & Adjustments – Once it’s ready, we’ll bring you in for a fitting to make sure everything feels perfect. If any minor tweaks are needed, we’ll make them right here in the office. And we’ll show you how to insert, remove, and clean your guard properly (more on this later).

Most patients are amazed at how seamless the process is—and even more amazed by how comfortable the final product feels. And of course, we’re just a phone call away if you ever need a replacement or adjustment down the line.

How to Care for and Maintain Your Custom Mouthguard

Your mouthguard is an investment in your health—so taking care of it ensures it lasts and continues to protect you effectively.

Here’s what we recommend:

✔️ Rinse it after each use with cool water or antibacterial mouthwash.

✔️ Clean it regularly with a soft toothbrush and non-abrasive toothpaste or a gentle soap.

✔️ Store it in a ventilated case to keep it dry and bacteria-free.

✔️ Avoid hot water—it can warp the material and affect the fit.

✔️ Bring it in during your dental visits so we can check it for wear and ensure it’s still doing its job.

When cared for correctly, a custom dental mouthguard can last several years. Many of our patients here in Oyster Bay have been using the same well-cared-for mouthguard for seasons—or even sleep cycles—without issue.

Finding the Best Provider for Custom Dental Mouthguards Near You

If you’re searching for “custom mouthguards near me,” it’s important to choose a provider who understands the importance of fit, comfort, and protection.

At Precision Oyster Bay, we craft custom mouthguards tailored to your unique bite—so you get the best protection possible. Whether you need a sports mouthguard, a night guard for teeth grinding, or an appliance for sleep apnea, we’ll make sure you’re covered.

Get in Touch for a Custom Mouthguard That Protects Your Smile

Your teeth are worth protecting, and a custom dental sports mouthguard is one of the best ways to keep them safe. Whether you’re an athlete, a teeth grinder, or just looking for extra protection, we’re here to help.

📞 Call us today at 516-922-5730 or check out our sleep apnea dental services to book an appointment today!

Frequently Asked Questions

How much do custom mouthguards cost?

Prices vary, but custom mouthguards typically range from $150 to $500, depending on the material and customization.

How long does a custom mouthguard last?

With proper care, a high-quality custom mouthguard can last several years.

Can I wear a custom mouthguard for teeth grinding?

Yes! If you suffer from bruxism (teeth grinding), a custom mouthguard—also known as a night guard—can help protect your teeth and prevent jaw pain.

Are custom mouthguards worth it?

Absolutely! Compared to store-bought options, they fit better, last longer, and offer superior protection.

Bibliography

“Mouth Guard”, clevelandclinic.org, January 10, 2023, https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/treatments/10910-mouthguards